The Power of Asking Your Insurance Prospects “Why?”

two women in conference meeting

Why do people buy insurance? Simple. Because they have to. It is a requirement of local, state, or federal governments. It is also required by an employer if contracted work takes place. Most importantly, it is required to have peace of mind. 

But just because it's required, doesn't mean they must get insurance from you. Why should someone get insurance from you? Simple. Because you understand their needs. 

Understanding their needs isn't simple, but it can be if you ask a simple question: “Why?” 

Why Do They Need Insurance?

This question requires you to look beyond the underwriting parameters. It helps you look at the reason that triggered the purchase. If they're currently insured then this question is why are they shopping?  

Maybe the current agency didn't provide enough coverage for a loss. Maybe they are trying to secure a contract for a job. Discovering why they need insurance will help you tailor the quote and explain why the coverages you selected best fits their needs. 

So, you give them a quote and they think they premium is high. What next?

Why is the price too high?

Is it high compared to what they are currently paying? Higher than other quotes they've received? Higher than they have budgeted for insurance? This price is never too high. The price is always relative. 

It's your job to figure out relative to what. When it comes to insurance, price is what they pay at the point of sale. If they feel the price is high, then they aren't seeing the value. The true cost will be seen over time.  It’s your job to help them see the value regardless of the cost.

Next, ask yourself…

Why should they buy from you?

According to the 2018 US Auto Insurance Study conducted by JD Power, cost is not the sole indicator of customer satisfaction in the auto insurance industry. To gain lasting, profitable clients, help the prospect see the value in working with you. They need to understand why you are better than the agency across the street.

Why didn't they buy from you?

This question isn't about the markets you are missing or something out of your control. It is about you. It's important to look at your performance. Determine if you could have qualified the prospect better. Or made an improvement in your execution. Did you provide a quote on time? Did you show value in working with your agency? 

Asking the prospect why increases your chances of closing the sale. Asking yourself why increases your chances of closing every sale. If you aren't asking why with every prospect, I ask you: Why not


What are some other why questions agents should ask to improve their sales process? Leave them in the comments below.


Previous Article
Running an Agency is like Learning to Drive
Running an Agency is like Learning to Drive

When it comes to running an insurance agency, you don't rise to the occasion. You fall to your level of pre...

Next Article
How to Modernize Your Insurance Agency’s Sales Techniques
How to Modernize Your Insurance Agency’s Sales Techniques

Have you updated your agency's sales techniques since the VCR or floppy disc was invented?